

I consume less while taking time off work because I drive less. Also, we are not so rigid about the bedtime routine while the kids are out of school, resulting in fewer children's books being read as well. Nonetheless, a couple of days ago I finished reading the fourth book in the Artemis Fowl series. As with the others, this was a fun book. The author's willingness to hurt and eliminate characters is refreshing, and makes the story less predictable.
One of the things about the Artemis Fowl books that I have been thinking the whole time I have read them, and thought again while reading this book is an author's dilemma with regards to technology. It seems that there is little that can date a book faster then the use of technology. If I write about how cool my CD collection is, a kid today certainly knows what a CD is, but the whole idea of collecting CDs as an actual source of music seems ridiculous today.
So part of the story line in the Artemis Fowl books is this idea that there is a parallel world of fairies living beneath the surface of the earth. The have a very similar social institutions to ours: television programs (including some reality TV), police forces, private detectives, and a lot of similar technology. One of the main differences is that their technology is far advanced to ours... so the author claims. But then in 2014, I am reading about how this crazy technologically advanced society has some really cutting edge technology that surrounds the idea of storing data on physical discs that people carry around with them.
Even by 2005 standards (the copyright of the text) the idea that a physical disc, as opposed to some solid state drive, seems a little dated. I know, I know, I know this is a young adult fantasy novel, I need to give it some leeway. I do, when it comes to fairies and dwarfs and trolls and all the other fantastical creatures. But the technology just dates the book.
I don't know what an author is supposed to do. Because technology is so much part of our lives, he can't simply leave it out, but how does he write about it in more of a timeless way? I realize he is not trying to write the novel of the century, but they are good books, and it would be nice if there was a way to solve the problem.
One of the things that I really enjoyed about the
Ender's Game series of books which I read this last year was the way the author addressed this issue. I don't want to give away any spoilers, but when it came to alien technology, it was as if they were doing things that humans just didn't even consider. The ten-year-old was able to read those books with me, and she seemed to really understand and enjoy them, so it is not as if writing in this way just doesn't appeal to the younger audience.
I guess it seems like it is the difference between an author that is looking to sell some pulp and one that wants a book to last.
Either way, I hope this criticism of the book doesn't dissuade anyone from reading the series. Overall I enjoyed the book, and the author's sense of humor. But I don't know that twenty years from now, the books will be enjoyed the way that I have re-enjoyed the Ender's Game series all these years later.
Format: audiobook
Read/don't read: read
You can find this book at Amazon.com here:
Artemis Fowl: The Opal Deception (Book 4)